possible sticky as well?
I decided id make the discussion forum so we dont spam up the entry forum
all discussion will take place i will put all the entries here

post what you like dont like
your favorite and who you think should win

Bucknasty:


Oc Log:


mel1441:


Wildirishman13:


Cali Ice:


Beau:


sureshot:



alright ill start it off curently i like beau's the most
the things i dont like about it is its a tad bit to bright
and also the text but im not really one to talk mine is shit

__________________

Bucknastey: I like it, but there's not much going on.
Oc LoG: I llove that! The clouds are great x], it flows nicely.
Mel1441: A bit basic imo, but it flashes, so it's ok.
Wildirshman13: I love the style, but you could have spent a bit longer on the vectored character.
Cali Ice: Nice, but you keep using that style :( (By keep I mean twice x])
Beau: I liked making it, but the gradient map is OTT, and I went half-arsed with my name.

That's me done XD. Wait, why did I comment on my own? lol.

EDIT: I don't want to shove my opinion down anyone's throat, I'm just sharing what I think. Also, is that my updated one?

__________________

beau kills it here. The only one im really interested in. A little too bright but really good.
Wildirishman13 u got a great idea but the vector is too plain, add more detail into the vector character and work on the text.

__________________

thanks for the comments

__________________

yea beus i think is the best so far =)

Bucknastey: it's cool.. but you need more pictures to make it nice
Mel1441: The flashes are a bit.. eh strange, try some various colors
Wildirshman13: nice idea but the guy in the middle needed some more colors
Cali Ice: it looks nice, only use another font
Beau: i like the lighting and picture! good text place, xD winner of sig of the week in my option

yeah i think we can all agree that beau owned us hands down its nice
i think oc log probably got second it looks really nice i love those clouds
and bucknastey make canvass smaller and put some more into it, it feels empts
and cali i feel his is too dark

__________________

(conrad swoops into the competition with the win!) lol well i doubt it but im still workin on myne =)

__________________

Beau's is the best in those *sprays* that how i like to call them... anyways.

__________________

if beau doesn't win, something is wrong. his sig has great depth and lighting. only major flaw is the text, which could be fixed simply by making the outer glow set to overlay.